Why Your Inner Editor Is Killing Your Creativity—And How to Shut It Up

If you’re judging your lyrics before they hit the page, you’re not writing—you’re editing a ghost.

And that’s how you lose the inner game of songwriting.

The Only Rule That Matters: Write or Lose

In songwriting, the scoreboard is simple:
You win when you write. You lose when you don’t.

It’s not about being faster, better, or more successful than someone else. It’s about having control over your own process.

The enemy isn’t time or talent. It’s the voice in your head whispering,

“That line’s not good enough.”
“This idea sucks.”
“Why even try?”

Let’s kill that voice with strategy.

🔁 Don’t Focus on Quality While You Write. It’s a Trap.

Yes, really. Quality is a trap when you’re in the writing phase.

The myth: If you aim for greatness while writing, you’ll get better songs.
The truth: If you aim for greatness while writing, you’ll freeze, overthink, and spiral.

To prove it, I run every student through an exercise called Write a Bad Song in 7 Steps. It’s exactly what it sounds like—and it works like magic. Why?

Because when you remove the pressure to be good, you finally start writing.

Here’s what happens:

• You write more ideas, faster.
• You get into flow state easier.
• You stop filtering yourself to death.

The real shocker?
It’s hard to write something truly awful because quality is baked into you. You’re wired to make things that survive and connect. That instinct never turns off.

So give yourself permission to suck. Ironically, that’s how the good stuff gets through.

⚔️ Separate the Two Selves: The Victor vs. The Defender

You’ve got two modes of operation:

• The Victor loves making things. It’s bold, fast, and full of dopamine.
• The Defender wants to protect you. It critiques, doubts, and plays it safe.

You need both. But not at the same time.

Trying to write and evaluate in the same breath is like hitting the gas and the brake together. You stall.

Instead, split the process:

Use a “Promotion Focus” to Generate Ideas:

Think about what you might gain.

Ask:

• “How many ideas can I generate in the next 5 minutes?”
• “How far can I push this concept?”
• “What’s the weirdest version of this idea I can try?”

Let your Victor win. Make a mess. It’s supposed to be wild.

Use a “Prevention Focus” to Edit Later:

This is Defender time. Now you’re protecting the work.

Ask:

• “What’s missing?”
• “What’s not working yet?”
• “What would confuse the listener?”

But don’t invite the Defender to your writing session. That’s like bringing a bouncer to a jam session.

🧠 Language Hack: Stop Saying These 3 Phrases

Your inner monologue matters. Every thought you repeat shapes your songwriting reality.

If you ever hear yourself say:

1. “This is terrible.”
2. “That won’t work.”
3. “This is a waste of time.”

Pause. Rewire. Say this instead:

• “What could I try next?”
• “How many ideas can I come up with in the next minute?”
• “What’s another way to say this?”

Self-talk is a software update. Install better code.

💡 Template: The “Bad Ideas First” Challenge

Try this today. It takes 10 minutes.

1. Set a timer for 5 minutes.
2. Write the worst song ideas you can think of—on purpose.
   (Yes, lines like “Your love’s like lukewarm soup” are welcome.)
3. Set another 5 minutes. Now ask: “Which of these could actually work?”

Bad ideas are often just raw ideas without polish. Give them a chance to evolve.

🧭 Final Note: Courage Over Perfection

Fear is natural. But courage is doing the thing anyway.

Courage is shutting up your inner editor and letting the ideas fly.
Courage is trusting your instincts enough to be messy first, and meticulous later.

So, stop trying to write a masterpiece every time.

Write more. Write faster. Write worse—so you can eventually write better.

Because in the end...

You don’t win by waiting for greatness.
You win by showing up.

Want help showing up consistently?

Check out the Speed Songwriting Mastery Program.
It's built to turn the "inner game" into muscle memory—fast.

👉 Learn more here

Download the FREE Speed Songwriting Cheat Sheet

You Can Start and Finish 365 Songs This Year, Know Exactly Where to Start and Exactly What to Say in Any Genre, All While Playing a Fun Game That Improves Your Skills Fast!

Enter your first name and email address below and click “GET ACCESS NOW!” to get the Speed Songwriting Cheat Sheet delivered to your inbox!

Enter Your First Name

Enter Your Email Address

We guarantee 100% privacy. Your information will not be shared.