Stuck on Titles? Steal This Songwriting Trick to Reignite Your Creative Spark

Ever stare at a blank page, waiting for a “brilliant” song title to just show up and tap you on the shoulder?

Stop waiting.

Here’s a simple, effective trick that’ll have your brain firing off hooks like fireworks: rewrite existing song titles.

It’s fast. It’s fun. And it works.

Even if you don’t use any of the titles you come up with, this exercise will kickstart your imagination and unlock new ideas—sometimes within hours, sometimes days. And occasionally, the right hook will drop in fully formed, gift-wrapped, and ready to write.

Let’s break it down.

Why This Works

Song titles aren’t just titles. They’re song seeds.

They carry rhythm, tone, emotion, genre, and often, the entire concept of the song.

Start with a strong title and you're already 80% there. A solid hook can pull the rest of the song into place like gravity.

When you play with existing titles, you’re reverse-engineering what works. You’re borrowing proven structure and twisting it into something fresh. You’re learning from the greats while building your own voice.

How To Rewrite Song Titles (Without Sounding Like a Copycat)

You’re not plagiarizing. You’re reimagining.

Here are 3 ways to flip a title and generate fresh material:

1. Flip the Meaning

Take the original sentiment and turn it upside down.

Example:

• “I Will Dare” by The Replacements → “You Won’t Risk It”
• “After Midnight” by Eric Clapton → “Before Noon”

The original says one thing. Your version says the opposite. It sparks contrast, tension, and curiosity. Great for irony or unexpected twists.

2. Keep the Rhythm, Change the Content

If the original title has a nice bounce or flow, keep the rhythm but swap the meaning.

Example:

• “Long Tall Sally” → “Big Bad Brady”
  (Same cadence. New character. Bonus points for alliteration.)

Use baby name sites, dictionaries, or even random word generators to shake things up.

3. Swap the Genre, Keep the Passion

Take the emotional core of a title and give it a stylistic twist.

Example:

• “I Love Rock ’n’ Roll” →
  “I Love Dance Punk”
  or
  “You Hate Rock and Roll?!”

Changing genres adds personality. Turning a bold declaration into a rhetorical question creates instant drama or humor.

Need Structure? Try These Title Rewriting Prompts

If you're stuck staring at a chart-topping title and drawing a blank, use one of these angle prompts to crack it open:

• Opposite emotion: Turn “Stay With Me” into “Leave Me Alone”
• Shift the time/place: “Welcome to the Jungle” → “Exit Through the Alley”
• Gender swap: “Father Figure” → “Mother Icon”
• Tone shift: “Kiss Me” → “Curse Me”
• Update slang or reference: “Hit the Road Jack” → “Log Off, Jack”
• Modernize the tech: “Paperback Writer” → “Substack Poet”

Try to match the syllables or rhythmic pattern of the original. Why? Because great titles often come with built-in musical phrasing. Matching that cadence gives you a head start on your melody.

Template Time: Your Song Title Generator

Here’s a fill-in-the-blank formula you can use anytime to riff on an existing title:

Original Title: [Insert hit song title]
New Title:

• Reverse the meaning
• Match the rhythm
• Use alliteration, rhyme, or internal repetition
• Swap the subject, time, or place

Repeat with 10 titles in 10 minutes. Don’t overthink it.

It’s like songwriting push-ups. You’ll feel stronger the next time you sit down to write.

Want to Take It Further?

Once you've got a rewritten title you like, try this:

• Write a one-line premise.
  What’s the story behind “Big Bad Brady”? Is he a villain? A misunderstood hero? A toddler with anger issues?
• List 3 visuals you associate with the title.
  For “Before Noon,” you might get:
  1. A sunrise over an empty street
  2. Cold coffee and unanswered texts
  3. An empty bed
• Write the first line of the chorus.
  Don’t aim for perfection. Aim for momentum.

Final Word: Make It a Habit

You don’t need a bolt of inspiration. You need a process that generates inspiration.

Set a timer. Scroll a Billboard chart. Rewrite 10 titles. Walk away.

One of them will stick.

And the next time you’re stuck mid-song with no hook in sight? You’ll have a stash of titles ready to go.

Get weird. Get bold. Get writing.

And when you land on something great, I want to hear it.

Download the FREE Speed Songwriting Cheat Sheet

You Can Start and Finish 365 Songs This Year, Know Exactly Where to Start and Exactly What to Say in Any Genre, All While Playing a Fun Game That Improves Your Skills Fast!

Enter your first name and email address below and click “GET ACCESS NOW!” to get the Speed Songwriting Cheat Sheet delivered to your inbox!

Enter Your First Name

Enter Your Email Address

We guarantee 100% privacy. Your information will not be shared.